The first address came back with an incomplete picture (56) and the second as a Fair match (66), and neither wins outright. The first has no traffic count nearby, so the road can't be confirmed, and recorded crime there is up 87% on the year before. The second has fewer unknowns, but its nearest primary has weaker results, 44% against 48%, and more recorded injury collisions, 10 against 6.
Both are on the client's own answers. The agent can show the client the evidence for each before a Saturday is spent on viewings.
From the written report for address one:
You asked for three things to work every week: schools, quiet, and broadband. Two of those come back strong. Broadband here is about as good as it gets, gigabit and superfast both reach 100% of the postcode, and the strategic noise modelling puts this address in a quieter band, with daytime road noise at 50.9 dB Lden. For a work-from-home base, that combination is the headline: fast, resilient internet and a calm backdrop to work against. Mobile signal backs it up too, with indoor 4G from at least one network reaching 100% of homes in the constituency.
Schools are the more complicated piece, and it is why the overall score sits at 56 rather than higher. There are three relevant schools close by, the nearest just 310 metres away, which is an easy walk for a school run. But the detail needs reading carefully rather than taken as a tick: the closest primary's 2024 results show only 48% of pupils reaching the expected standard in reading, writing and maths, against results elsewhere that are often higher, and admissions are not guaranteed by distance alone. Alongside that, within 500 metres there have been 6 police-reported injury collisions over three years, including 2 serious ones and incidents involving a pedestrian and two cyclists, which matters directly if the school run means crossing local roads on foot or by bike. Neither finding is a dealbreaker on its own, but together they mean schools need a site visit and a call to the council before you treat this as settled.